Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 November 2014

DirecTV wins race to 4K, but stuck with Samsung TVs

DirecTV has begun its 4K content rollout this week, becoming the first of the US pay TV companies to do so. The largest US satellite provider, and second largest pay TV company, has made 19 4K films from Paramount and IMAX-specialist K2 Communications available via its Genie DVR for consumers to download over the internet – but at launch consumers will need an RVU and HEVC compatible Samsung 4K TV to use the service.

While the science and nature documentary content from K2 makes up the bulk of the catalog, instead of the Hollywood blockbusters that might better frame a significant marketing push, the infrastructure needed to deliver the titles has been pushed to the sidelines. For reasons currently not made clear, the Genie is not able to simply push a signal to any 4K-capable TV over HDMI.

In the end this is a “me too” make-do announcement and not a viable, valuable OTT service.

There is also no justification of the requirement for a 2014 Samsung TV in the announcement, and neither is there any mention of how the customer goes about receiving the 4K content – likely because the reality is push VoD overnight satellite downloads and that’s not a particularly marketable feature. Earlier this month, DirecTV CEO Mike White revealed the service on an earnings call, but with the caveat that content would have to be downloaded overnight to the DVR, due to the huge file sizes involved.

However, after some digging, it turns out that all of Samsung’s 2014 UHD TVs support HEVC, as well as HDMI 2.0, which has sufficient bandwidth to push 4K resolutions at 60 frames per second to the TV. But there’s no clear verdict on whether all the DirecTV Genies also support HEVC – and consequently, why they can’t simply push a HEVC signal to any compatible HEVC-ready TV.

In addition, of the 14 UHD TVs that are currently listed on Samsung’s website, only two declare themselves to be DirecTV Ready – the 85-inch UN85S9A and UN85S9V, both priced at an exorbitant $40,000. But this is misleading, as the actual feature that is required for DirecTV’s new 4K library appears to be RVU functionality – which allows a TV to receive a picture from the Genie without having to connect an additional receiver to the TV.

While the DirecTV for Samsung marketing departments obviously need to sit down and decide on some clearer branding, all 14 of Samsung’s UHD models have RVU functionality. RVU (R-View) was developed by the RVU Alliance, founded by Broadcom, Cisco, DirecTV and Samsung. It is based on HTML5 and is compatible with DLNA and UPnP, and the alliance claims that 20 million RVU devices have been sold in the US, a number we find highly unlikely.

As well as Samsung, Sony has RVU functionality in some of its Bravia TVs, and Toshiba has RVU on one device too. However none of these TVs are UHD, and so it seems that only Samsung had the RVU+UHD compatibility together needed at launch – perhaps a sign of the lack of enthusiasm for RVU among OEMs.

As for set tops; Pace, Humax, and Technicolor build the DirecTV-branded units which support RVU. We reached out for clarification of whether any of the set tops involved were HEVC compatible, but have yet to hear back. We will update you if this changes. But if the set tops do not support HEVC, it looks like the RVU criteria is required to push the untreated 4K signal from the Genie to the RVU-UHD TVs, to be decoded in the Samsung set.

Once again 4K adoption is hampered by the last mile internet connection. Where customers do have TVs and set tops which can handle the decoding, many still lack the bandwidth needed for live streaming – and so have to pick a movie now to watch tomorrow and let the set top download the content while they are asleep or away from home. White did reveal that subscribers would have a few 4K titles downloaded onto their DVRs in order to sample the service.

White also said that DirecTV’s 4K service would expand on the back of the launch and installation of a new satellite in Q1 2015 by Arianespace, built by Space Systems. Boosting the capacity available from its satellites to the home which would allow the company to start offering 4K channels in its TV packages in a similar manner to how HD channels were first pushed to consumers. Dedicated 4K movie channels would also allow DirecTV to bypass the bottleneck of the last mile internet connection too.