Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 September 2015

Elemental says HDR belongs in software; standards still unstable

Elemental Technologies has published a white paper proposing that video providers will benefit most by implementing support for High Dynamic Range (HDR) in software rather than hardware, due to the uncertainty of standardizations.

The report, entitled ‘High Dynamic Range Video – Implementing Support for HDR using Software-Defined Video Solutions,’ states that there is no guarantee that a single approach to HDR will be agreed upon any time soon.

Content owners in particular face issues surrounding standardization, for example, a content owner might be asked to deliver HDR content in two different formats for two different distributors – which will pose difficulties when it tries to market its library for reuse and rebroadcast. However, Elemental says it has the answer, “By creating a software-based HDR infrastructure using video solutions from Elemental, new and vibrant color and luminance standards can be implemented today without forcing expensive decisions or the maintenance of running parallel hardware-based HDR silos.”

Elemental believes we could be waiting a while before we see any real stability concerning standardized approaches to HDR for traditional and OTT delivery and says there are two major components to take into consideration. Firstly, is whether or not a particular system is backwards compatible, and secondly, is how the backwards compatible metadata for HDR and SDR is transmitted.

Philips, Dolby, Technicolor and BBC/NHK are all working on standards based approaches, but currently the most well-known is HDR10, a combination of specifications from the Society of Motion Picture & Television Engineers. Also, MPEG is adding supplemental enhancement information (SEI) messages to its HEVC standard to support HDR.

Some big players have been developing techniques for implementing HDR and others are pushing for open methods to avoid a VHS versus Betamax situation.

There is also uncertainty at other levels of the ecosystem, for example encoding. Recent events such as Ericsson’s acquisition of Envivio and Amazon’s of Elemental, suggest that the tide is moving towards software encoding. The number of situations where software running on off the shelf silicon, either CPUs or GPUs, is increasing and will continue to do so. But at the same time ever more demanding encoding scenarios arrive, since new generations of technology come along precisely because increasing hardware power makes it possible to design new, more efficient, but more computationally intensive, algorithms. The software brigade argue that CPUs and GPUs provide that power, but some admittedly not entirely impartial observers such as Ericsson’s head of TV compression Giles Wilson insisted at IBC that there would still be a place for hardware on the live encoding side.

“HDR is important and the industry wants it sooner rather than later given its obvious visual appeal and potential to stimulate UHD device and service uptake,” said Mike Callahan, Senior Director of Solutions Marketing at Elemental. “Software-defined video solutions from Elemental give content programmers a key advantage: flexible, scalable HDR infrastructures that support live and VOD services and easily keep pace with rapid change. It’s a powerful complement to the Technicolor HDR workflow, which provides features, such as backward compatibility, for simplifying workflows and reducing storage and delivery costs.”

Technicolor and Elemental were showcasing their collaborative HDR with backward compatibility at this year’s IBC, which demonstrated what is apparently the world’s first broadcast delivery system of 4K UHD HDR video. The live footage was passed through the 4K/HEVC Elemental Live video encoder, before being delivered to a Technicolor set top, where it was decoded and displayed on an HDR-capable TV. The system is able to upscale High Frame Rate (HFR) 4K SDR events, including live sports, to HDR and this compatibility will soon be added to TVs, including several of Sony’s 4K UHD TVs.

BT Sport announced the launch of its UHD 4K sports channel at Ericsson’s IBC press conference, and said it is looking to add HDR capabilities, possibly in two years and Sky has said it is in the process of testing HDR.