Comcast’s Xfinity Mobile venture was viewed by many industry observers as an unassuming entrant into the mobile arena, providing minimal threat to existing US mobile network operators. Almost one year on since Xfinity Mobile made its debut, Comcast is bulking up its mobile back end operations through a partnership deal with Charter – to accelerate Xfinity Mobile services as well as Charter’s soon-to-launch Spectrum Mobile MVNO venture.
A common platform for operations such as mobile billing between the two US cable operators has been public knowledge since Comcast unveiled Xfinity Mobile, yet this week’s joint announcement reveals the collaboration is even closer than initially assumed – potentially preparing for a mega merger following Comcast’s rejected pursuit of Sky in the same week.
In addition, the two operators say the joint mobile operating platform is intended to encourage further MVNO launches, serving as the systems interface for any current and future MVNO partners. Sprint could be the first such partner, albeit wary of repeating the failed Pivot project launched back in 2004 between Sprint, Comcast, Time Warner Cable, Cox and Advance/Newhouse, flopping after four years due to billing and network integration issues.
The joint platform will handle customer sales, support, device logistics, warehousing and billing. However, Comcast and Charter stress that all customer-facing activities including customer service, marketing, sales, pricing and packaging will continue to be maintained individually, and the same is true for relationships with device manufacturers.
The announcement implies the software platform and related back end systems have been 100% developed in-house, although Comcast confirmed to Faultline Online Reporter there are some unnamed vendor relationships in place as suspected, saying “very few platforms of this type can be fully built in-house”. Comcast’s representative added that “design, infrastructure and integration was done 100% in-house by Comcast and Charter,” suggesting a billing system is the key missing element.
Both operators use CSG International to handle cable billing services within their back-office infrastructures, which recently won a contract extension at Charter to consolidate Time Warner Cable and Bright House Networks customers, although there was no mention of this contract extension taking on mobile operations for either operator.
Mobile services bring with them a new world of complexities but a browse through CSG International’s portfolio suggests the company has the assets to power billing services and more for a platform such as this, but then so too do other operations like Amdocs, as nothing is a given in billing. In the same way authentication and identity management, especially taking in WiFi offload, is likely to be with one of the major cellular suppliers like Nokia or Ericsson. What is clear is that Comcast and Charter want real control and better integration in these areas, not just the off the shelf MVNO apps which smaller MVNOs have had to settle for in the US.
On the surface, the alliance gives the impression Charter has licensed the Xfinity Mobile operating platform to power Spectrum Mobile, but with some of its own modifications. A Comcast representative insisted that is not the case, reiterating the project is a collaborative effort, without being able to confirm specifically what additional technology Charter is bringing to the table.
The idea is to combine operational data and technologies to enhance the platform over the years, to the extent it could become a major back end force for future technologies such as 5G. Again Comcast made it clear that there is no current focus on 5G or any future technology, focusing instead on getting Charter’s Spectrum Mobile off the ground and building momentum for Xfinity Mobile.
On the new technology front, the breadth of the cooperation will create something more influential than just a deployment partnership. It looks more like CableLabs, the US cable industry’s standards and R&D organization, in wireless. Think of it as WirelessLabs.
The companies have both been involved in testing technologies in 5G high frequency spectrum and they could conceivably pool their efforts, and even their joint holdings of 214,000 fiber route miles, which “could provide a critical backbone that would enable the densification anticipated for 5G services”, as Walter Piecyk of analyst firm BTIG put it.
However financially Charter is funding the entirety of the project initially “to reflect certain developments costs that Comcast has already made in mobile-related platforms and technology.” At some point in the future, costs associated with the platform will be split evenly once the spend to date has levelled off.
Each operator’s version of the platform will work independently but will be jointly governed by a board of directors comprising two directors each from Comcast and Charter.
Xfinity Mobile is projected to climb steadily to exceed 1 million subscribers this quarter and pick up pace next year to close in on 3 million by Q3 2019, according to New Street Research. Charter’s Spectrum Mobile is forecast to experience similar slow growth at first before ramping up sharply. At that rate, once both of them hit 1 million a quarter, in late 2019/early 2020, they will be taking 8 million subscribers a year from AT&T, Verizon and Sprint.
All this noise points back to the idea Comcast and Charter each separately take an interest in Verizon, and effectively take joint control. Verizon is of course the MVNO partner for both. It is not surprising then that last week there were renewed rumors of a merger between T-Mobile and Sprint.
A jointly developed mobile operating platform is a signal to Verizon that MVNO services are just the beginning – setting their sights on a much bigger mobile prize perhaps five or six years away. Can you imagine the carnage in AT&T and Sprint’s valuation when smartphones have stopped growing, they are looking about 4 million subscribers a year and 5G costs are escalating. Verizon will only have the balancing fact that all these customers are using its network, through MVNOs.
But with that fact comes the thought that overnight these two cable firms could dump Verizon and instead acquire Sprint or T-Mobile. That thought will depress the Verizon stock sufficiently that if Comcast and Charter wished to buy stock to take a strong minority position, it would be cheap. From there it is a short step to placing people on the Verizon board in return for not leaving the Verizon fold and opening up 5G to them. John Malone is perhaps the best exponent of holding minority stakes in multiple companies in order to avoid regulatory concerns and that’s precisely what we expect here.
Danny Bowman, Chief Mobile Officer for Charter, said, “Our new partnership will enable us to drive faster and more cost-effective mobile product and service enhancements and provide innovative and affordable mobile service to our customers. We are excited about the launch of Spectrum Mobile in the coming months.”
Comcast Chief Business Development Officer Sam Schwartz said: “We have built a best-in-class mobile platform for Xfinity Mobile that is resonating with customers. By collaborating with Charter, we will help drive operational and cost efficiencies for both companies.”