As expected, Disney has trumped Comcast’s bid for 21st Century Fox. What caught us slightly off guard though, was that Disney would raise Comcast’s offer by a substantial $6.3 billion, offering the Murdoch family a cool $71.3 billion of approximately 50% cash and 50% stock – which the Fox board has since accepted.
We are prepared to be proven wrong as Comcast may well retreat with its tail between its legs, but we are sticking to our Comcast-prevailing guns and would like to raise a potential third outcome – one to please both parties by avoiding a brutal bidding war and thereby prevent plunging the eventual auction winner into insurmountable debt.
Both bidders seem intent on owning 100% of UK operator Sky, yet Comcast may be able to throw Disney a sweetener. Comcast could suggest carving up the deal, playing the devil on the shoulder of Disney and whispering in its ear “why would you want to own 39% in a satellite TV operator, when we are going to bid for the 61% you don’t own anyway?”.
This would give Disney and its shareholders some serious food for thought, in that Comcast could offer to help Disney out with cash, to ease debt following the takeover of 21st Century Fox, and in exchange Comcast would get its hands on Sky.
We confess this is a highly contentious idea, as any sort of agreement between Comcast and Disney would certainly catch industry observers by surprise, yet it’s a win-win outcome from our point of view and investors will agree. Any sort of share-deal springing up is hindered however by the sheer determination and downright arrogance of both companies, which could exacerbate this bidding war beyond the bounds of reason.
A more likely next step then is for Comcast to simply match Disney’s bid, but with a stock offer to make up the remaining $6.3 billion. That would make Comcast’s offer the better of the two in terms of cash, going from an all-cash $65 billion bid to a 91% cash and 9% stocks and shares offer.
Despite Comcast putting much more cash on the table, media mogul Murdoch gives the impression he would rather accept an inferior cash offer from Disney, in confidence that Fox assets will contribute to Disney growth in the future and therefore returns will prove more prosperous in the long run. There are also tax issues tied to cash offers which Rupert Murdoch and other shareholders will be eager to avoid, while stock consideration is expected to be tax-free to Fox shareholders.
“We firmly believe that this combination with Disney will unlock even more value for shareholders as the new Disney continues to set the pace at a dynamic time for our industry. We remain convinced that the combination of 21CF’s iconic assets, brands and franchises with Disney’s will create one of the greatest, most innovative companies in the world,” commented Murdoch.
A critical component often overlooked by news outlets is how will banks view the situation? Going by growth and track record of debt repayments, Comcast comes out with a meticulous credit score – yet the company still finds itself with consolidated net debt of $61.4 billion prior to any acquisition of Fox and/or Sky assets.
Of course, the contrasting types of offers mean Comcast’s net debt would be much greater should a deal go through, while Disney plus Fox would have net debt in the region of $97 billion. Certain reports are missing the point that Comcast and Disney have almost identical market caps (Comcast valued at $152.6 billion and Disney at $161 billion) and there is no guarantee Disney’s future strategy will secure value, particularly given its track record in OTT video.
Both Comcast and Disney are recruiting investment banks to fund their offers, of which somewhere between $16 billion to $18 billion is estimated to be for Sky, while Fox is attempting to buy the 61% of shares it does not already own in the UK outfit.
It’s worth repeating a point we highlighted earlier on in the Fox bidding saga about Comcast’s debt history. The world’s largest entertainment company ended 2017 with a healthy, low debt-to-equity ratio of 0.94, lower even than Apple, Amazon and Netflix. Even if Comcast eventually takes on Fox for $70+ billion, its debt-to-equity ratio would still be lower than average – suggesting the offers being made are perhaps not as outlandish as first glance suggests. Keeping its debt below about 5x EBITDA is an important feat to continue operating healthily.
Meanwhile, Disney has slipped UK regulators a sweetener of its own, committing to operating the loss-making Sky News for the next 15 years on the condition it cannot be sold off without the UK government’s say so. Comcast recently promised it would establish a Sky News board for at least a period of 10 years to ensure Sky News remained independent.
Disney CEO Bob Iger’s latest statement reads: “The acquisition of 21st Century Fox will bring significant financial value to the shareholders of both companies, and after six months of integration planning we’re even more enthusiastic and confident in the strategic fit of the assets and the talent at Fox. At a time of dynamic change in the entertainment industry, the combination of Disney’s and Fox’s unparalleled collection of businesses and franchises will allow us to create more appealing high-quality content, expand our direct-to-consumer offerings and international presence, and deliver more personalized and compelling entertainment experiences to meet growing consumer demand around the world.”