Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 July 2018

Telefónica mulls fixed line sale with mobile-first video in mind

A fly on the wall of Telefónica’s boardroom has leaked news of a potential partial sale of fixed line network assets in Spain, accounting for a sizable share of Europe’s largest FTTH network connecting 20 million homes, according to local news outlet El Confidencial.

With such a dominant share of the market, breaking up fixed line assets to create a more competitive environment for internet and pay TV services could be a positive for consumers. Both Vodafone, through its acquisition of cable operator Ono, and Orange, which bought fiber and mobile operator Jazztel, have been hot on the heels of the Spanish incumbent – investing rapidly in fiber both for the home and for cellular backhaul.

Telefónica is unlikely to initiate a sale of assets to the chasing pack however, should El Confidencial’s source prove credible. A more liable outcome would be striking a deal with infrastructure funds, which have been circling Telefónica’s assets since it sold off 40% of its submarine cable and tower business to private equity group KKR for €1.27 billion ($1.5 billion) last year.

Telefónica’s board of directors are apparently considering erecting a for sale sign to pay off debt and thereby bump up stock prices, which have struggled this year – dropping 9%. Telefónica ended 2017 with net financial debt of €44.23 billion ($51.7 billion), although it managed to cut this down by €4.36 billion ($5.1 billion) in a year.

Spain’s FTTH penetration has reached 7 million homes, adding 1.8 million connections in a year, according to recent data from government agency CNMC (Comision Nacional de los Mercados y de la Competencia). Telefónica’s Movistar dominates with a 50.4% share of the Spanish FTTH market. In pay TV, Movistar accounts for the majority of Spain’s 4 million IPTV subs with gains there offsetting losses in satellite.

While we think it’s unlikely a partial sale of certain assets would mark a precursor to a full-frontal exit from the fixed line network market by Telefónica, it would be naive to rule out such a scenario, as Telefónica has managed to reach deals with Orange and Vodafone in Spain to share fiber costs and Vodafone has done similar deals in Portugal.

Similar situations are occurring elsewhere in Europe, with Germany the prime example, a market in danger of being reduced to just two fixed line players as Vodafone is poised to buy key assets from Liberty Global, pending a decision from German competition regulator the Bundeskartellamt.

Around a decade ago we saw the value of ISPs all over Europe shoot up, as purely cellular operations like Vodafone, and to some extent all the European majors outside their home markets, were on the hunt for fixed lines over which to deliver Quality of Service controlled video services – in other words, video good enough for the TV.

Nordic telco Tele2 has been a busy player in fixed line M&A across Europe, notably its historic selling spree between 2005 and 2013. So like Tele2, Telefónica could be set to step back from fixed lines and focus on mobile operations. The operator has some 12 million mobile subscribers in Spain and mobile-first video is driving the growth of Movistar Fusión TV, adding 1.3 million mobile users in the last year compared to an uptake of 500,000 viewers on traditional TV sets.

Some series on the core Movistar Fusión TV service have even been made mobile exclusives, serving up multiscreen for just €7 a month, although this might be more of a rights issue than choice.

Telefónica published figures this week claiming 10 million people in Spain view Movistar+ content every day, saying it calculated viewing data from its installed base of 4 million set tops. Telefónica never clarified how its devices are able to identify the number of people viewing the same screen at any given time, so we suspect the operator has simply multiplied 4 million by the average household size in Spain of 2.5 individuals.

It also said 20% of viewing is catch-up content and 80% of subscribers favor à la carte offerings, with 200 minutes of average daily viewing time.

“Television has shown itself to be a generator of loyalty among customers, who appreciate a convergent, complete and differentiated service, in which Movistar+ plays an essential role. The proof of that is that we have a lower level of churn among customers that have a television subscription than among those who do not. And more and more customers with convergent packages are enjoying television, already touching 80%,” said Emilio Gayo, Telefónica Spain’s President.