Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 July 2018

WBU joins C-band rendition of Cry Me a River, execs predict chaos

Backstabbing and U-turning have been common themes among the satellite community, encapsulating the state of disarray which has engulfed companies once so powerful. This week, the World Broadcasting Unions (WBU) touched on the sensitive C-band subject – describing the scenario which will ensue from the sale of spectrum to cellular players as “chaos”.

As we know, the FCC is currently in the process of digesting plans to reallocate C-band frequencies, in the 3.7 GHz to 4.2 GHz range, where hundreds of thousands of C-band fixed satellite services (FSS) downlink sites operate – as satellite fleet operators prepare to cash in. The impending reality for satellite firms outside the US is that, eventually, copycat situations will arise, while in the US, the worry is that cellcos will eat up more and more spectrum – with insiders projecting the 100 MHz proposed slice of C-band spectrum falling the way of 5G will be just the beginning.

Made up of seven regional broadcasting bodies, the WBU said: “The potential allocation of C-band FSS spectrum to mobile services will create chaos to the economics of broadcasting by satellite, potentially interrupting services to audiences around the world. Furthermore, C-band is critical for satellite services in tropical regions as it suffers less from the attenuation effects of heavy rainfall than higher frequency bands.”

The WBU’s statement is a perfect follow on from Faultline Online Reporter’s coverage of ConnecTechAsia last week, describing a tension in the air around the satellite hall which resulted in some interesting conversations. Coincidentally, ConnecTechAsia wasn’t the only TV technology event in Singapore last week playing host to satellite community backlash.

Just down the road, C-band debates raged at the CASBAA (Cable and Satellite Broadcasting Association of Asia) Industry Forum, where newly appointed CEO of AsiaSat, Roger Tong, said, “My personal belief is that Intelsat sold out the industry. Once cellular operators get C-band, they won’t stop. They will be more and more bandwidth hungry, they will claim to have more devices out there, they will claim that their market segment is expanding so they have to expand the spectrum.”

As the first satellite fleet operator to submit a proposal to open up access to C-band satellite spectrum for 5G network usage, Intelsat (with help from Intel) unlocked the gates for the largest satellite fleet firm, SES, to make an abrupt about face after initially branding Intelsat a traitor. The satellite industry needs a scapegoat, so debt-riddled Intelsat is as good as any, with the company looking to cut its losses and others beginning to accept dire straits.

CASBAA attendees voiced some strong opinions, with EVP of holding company APT Satellite, Huang Baozhong, adding: “This is a disaster for the whole industry. I am 100% sure that most other countries will follow and then this will be spread all over the world. They will take another 100 MHz or 200 MHz until finally all the C-band will be gone.”

Sensing panelists were becoming passionately over protective, CEO of Eutelsat Asia, Jean-François Fenech, said, “The good thing I observe is many of the countries have national satellite systems which are operating in C-band, so I don’t see how they would shoot themselves in the foot if they believe satellite in C-band is good for them.”

WBU’s input is significant, with the union comprising the North American Broadcasters Association, European Broadcasting Union, International Association of Broadcasting, Asia Pacific Broadcasting Union, Arab States Broadcasting Union, African Union of Broadcasting and Caribbean Broadcasting Union. Our honest view is that with so much money on the table, the union’s plea to rally together will be ignored – as some estimates value just 100 MHz of C-band spectrum in the $billions.

“C-Band FSS downlink frequencies between 3,400-4,200 MHz, have been and are extensively used throughout the world by WBU members for Fixed Satellite Services (FSS) applications and will continue to be used for the foreseeable future, in particular above 3,600 MHz. Since FSS downlink sites receive extremely weak signals from satellites in geosynchronous orbit, they are particularly fragile and susceptible to interference. WBU members have experienced serious interference to services where this spectrum has been opened up to other users and, because few countries require these receive-only downlink sites to be licensed or registered, little recourse is available. The WBU encourages our members to register their downlink sites,” said a WBU statement.

“Satellite services have long provided valuable broadcasting services and remain an essential part of often complex broadcast supply chains serving our audiences, both nationally and internationally, for public service and commercial broadcasters,” it continued.

While the WBU has waxed lyrical about the implications for its beloved industry, has offering some sort of compromise crossed the minds of its members? Apparently not. Meanwhile, even Google managed to propose some sort of “win-win-win” situation to satisfy mobile, satellite and fixed wireless players – suggesting opening up 100 MHz of spectrum at 3.7 GHz to 3.8 GHz for mobile 5G in densely populated urban areas.

Although it might be this slice of spectrum the WBU is most concerned about, adding: “WBU members therefore call on satellite service providers and government regulators to protect the availability of the upper part of the C-Band spectrum, where the band has been allocated to satellite services and is currently used to provide many broadcasting services, enabling broadcasters around the world to continue to provide vital broadcasting services to billions of people across the world.”