Every major anti-trust trial goes the same way. If you can’t win the case, win the appeal, if you can’t win that, cry foul and claim the judge/commission/directorate are biased against you.
Perhaps that’s why we’re not surprised at the Microsoft accusation this week, that the EC has collaborated with its competitors behind its back.
In each case, for instance in IBM’s anti-trust case, first against the US Justice Department, and then against the European Commission, IBM cried foul. It managed to destroy the careers of quite a few people, but in the end it did IBM no good. It went through five years of zero growth, and staggered to find new ways of doing things, and finally went for a change in management which eventually saved the company.
After hearing the complaint EC Commissioner Neelie Kroes was reported by the Dow Jones Newswires as saying that Microsoft’s conduct was likely to lead to heavier and heavier fines.
Once again Microsoft has lobbied for the US government to intervene, but of course, the companies that Microsoft is harming in the market are mostly US companies anyway, and where they are not, companies like Nokia employ large numbers of US citizens.
Microsoft was always going to target the EC technical adviser, Neil Barrett because he has a lot of control over Microsoft’s activities. Saying he has had ‘inappropriate’ contact with Microsoft competitors is a little bit like accusing him of playing unfair because he refuses to do as he is told by Microsoft.
Microsoft has hardly performed like IBM. Its revenues are still going up and its profits still rise, just much more slowly than in previous years. Its share price however has not budged for almost 3 years. The current management give investors no reason to buy Microsoft shares, and by raising the prospect of more punitive measures down the line from the EU, harm investors further. The likely outcome will be that Ballmer could take the fall in the same way that John Akers took the fall for IBM back in 1986, in order to sweep away Microsoft’s bundling habits forever.
We can remember interviewing John Akers before his fall back in the 80s, and he refused to answer difficult questions and arrogantly said that everything was right with IBM. That was days before he stood down.