Qualcomm has really done a number on DVB-H in the US, and by tying up a deal with best customer Verizon Wireless very early on last year, it has somehow managed to position DVB-H as untrustworthy, underperforming, unproven and an also ran, when in fact the opposite is true.
The Qualcomm affect is so intense that this week saw the CEO of Modeo, Michael Schueppert, resign from the company that has now scheduled a NY only launch of Mobile TV, without a single cellular operator helping out the marketing effort.
The resignation was referred to in this week’s SEC filings for parent Crown Castle and said simply that Michael Ramke had been appointed as interim president in his place. Remke is currently the vice president of marketing and business development.
Around the rest of the world cellular operators from Vietnam to Finland, from Australia to South Africa, have been more than willing to take on DVB-H in a number of spectrum and despite everything that Qualcomm continues to say about what started life as a Europe standard out of the DVB Project, it is still on track to both perform as well as Qualcomm’s MediaFLO, and cost roughly the same to deploy in the same spectrum.
We have aired debates giving Qualcomm its say, but this has tended to be contradicted almost unanimously by transmitter suppliers, network integrators and the core DVB-H players, including Nokia.
The score sheet so far globally reads something like MediaFLO 1 partner, 3 or 4 trials; DVB-H three live services, 30 trials, and yet Cingular Wireless has refused to commit to working with either Modeo, which has operated a prolonged Pittsburgh DVB-H trial for around a year, or HiWire, which will begin a trial in a few weeks. And MediaFLO only got itself off the ground by Qualcomm buying its own spectrum and risking $800 million in build out and technology costs.
The problem has always been spectrum. HiWire has better spectrum than Modeo for in-building penetration and longer distance propagation, in the 700 MHz UHF range, similar to MediaFLO. Meanwhile Modeo has spectrum in 1.6 GHz which has implications for how it must go about building its network. Whether it operates around the highest power limits and has expensive gap filler sites, or whether it opts for a denser, but lower power network, it will still incur a financial penalty in network build costs of between 50% more than the costs incurred by Qualcomm, and as high as double the costs.
But most of the reticence to partnering Modeo is as much about DVB-H per se, as it is about having what is considered less appropriate spectrum. After all once the network build out costs are committed, the Opex costs are minimally higher on non-UHF spectrum. Crown Castle has the advantage of owning thousands of tower sites around the US, and can dramatically reduce its own costs by relying on its existing assets.
Other filings show that Crown Castle has just raised $1.5 billion in fresh debt, partly to replace older debt and partly to provide funds needed for buying rival Global Signal. Crown Castle only ever holds around $65 million in cash at any one time and throws off close to $200 million in cash each year. But this might not be enough to fund a full US build out.
When Modeo was first announced, the company had a clear 6 month lead on Qualcomm, a lead it killed overnight by getting its best customer Verizon to reverse a decision to go with DVB-H and instead back its own MediaFLO, even before it was tested or demonstrated in field conditions, which has proved a master stroke.
Since then Sprint has declared that it will build its own network in WiMAX, and has even trialed MediaFLO just in case it provides an interim option, and Cingular has sat firmly on the fence, spending more on its own, less efficient unicast mobile TV service built around MobiTV, which seems to suggest it won’t climb down any day soon.
DVB-H will continue to benefit from all those other trials around the world, which drives competition in the handset market and drives prices down. Even Qualcomm is due, next quarter, to release a chip that supports both MediaFLO and DVB-H on the same device.
In October the Telecommunications Industry Association (TIA) adopted DVB-H as an official standard for Mobile Digital TV in the US, partly because last January a group of heavyweights including Intel, Motorola, Nokia, Microsoft and Texas Instruments formed a pressure group to push DVB-H in the US called the Mobile Digital TV Alliance
With the departure of its subsidiary’s CEO, Crown Castle could be finding its sortie into mobile TV a little rich for its blood and its cash supply, and Crown Castle may need to reach out to the Mobile DTV Alliance partners and ask them to stump up some of the much needed cash to build out a US wide mobile TV service, but first it’s got to prove that it can make revenues from its New York service.
The New York installation is thought to be using 80 to 90 lower power transmitters each costing in the region of $125,000, with total build out costs being way over $12 million for one City. Both DVB-H and MediaFLO involve building out separate new networks, so non-handset portable devices can also be built to take TV on the go, as well as building receivers iinto handsets. These will cost somewhere between $100 or $200 for one with built in storage to offer DVR capabilities.
Modeo must now get some manufacturers to show interest in providing these in the New York area, with the right RF tuners for its network. TV can be added to devices that already have a screen and applications processor for about $10 worth of chips, however there is a lot of design and upfront manufacturing set up costs for each new device.
Modeo can also sell handsets directly that attach to all of the cellular networks, but without the blessing of the cellular operators, and also try to court the minor cellcos such as Alltel. One such is T-Mobile, that now has the spectrum to do more in the US after recent auctions, but it has already committed to both a HiWire and a MediaFLO trial, which appears once more to leave Modeo in the cold.
One suggested move is for Modeo and HiWire to merge, and use the HiWire spectrum to deliver TV. This could be achieved if the right private equity groups get involved, but would they really want to take on the might of Qualcomm.
Modeo is scheduled to detail its service in the first week in January, when it will reveal content and retail partners.