Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 February 2020

Targeted ad spec will extend HbbTV legacy for European broadcasters

The HbbTV Association’s announcement of its specification for targeted advertising should sustain the technology for the European and especially German commercial broadcasters already on board, but fail to win new recruits. Called HbbTV-TA, the association as good as admits the limitations of its ambition with its boast that it has huge potential for adoption in Europe as the first open standard dedicated to targeted advertising in broadcast TV.

It argues erroneously that HbbTV-TA will enable new business models and revenue sources that have so far been “largely restricted to the advertising market on the internet or OTT/streaming services.” It fails to mention the few proprietary platforms that have emerged, most notably Sky’s AdSmart developed with help from remnants of Cisco now incorporated in Synamedia. AdSmart is being widely adopted now throughout the larger Comcast empire including NBCUniversal after its takeover of Sky, while also gaining converts among other operators such as Liberty Global’s UK cableco Virgin Media.

AdSmart is not confined to pay TV having been adopted by UK broadcaster Channel 4, and was considered by ITV, but HbbTV is purely for the broadcast domain and unlikely to gain many new converts now. HbbTV-TA is designed to satisfy the existing base and should succeed in doing that by enabling them to deliver addressable ads tailored to individual homes like AdSmart, although in a different way. AdSmart downloads ads over the broadcast medium satellite to the set top and therefore relies on storage and processing there to target the TV.

HbbTV-TA on the other hand delivers the substitute ads over the internet connection for splicing into the broadcast, so in theory can target individuals as well as the whole household, although more likely by broad attributes like the content genre, or based on locality. The “default” ad on the TV channel’s conventional broadcast feed is replaced on a screen-by-screen basis with the specified targeted ad.

This is the latest chapter for HbbTV, which initially harbored ambitions of conquering Europe and then moving on to gain territory elsewhere in the world, rather like the parallel DVB specifications. In practice, it has been confined to a subset of DVB’s terrain, largely the central European area around Germany and France where it emerged in 2009, initially focused on interactive services for broadcasters, primarily catch-up and red-button type alternative channels, as well as news feeds and participation in games shows.

HbbTV then evolved into a hybrid service for incorporation of online content, but still broadcast-centric, requiring retention of a tuner in the set top. This allowed broadcasters to introduce a basic level of ad targeting through insertion of graphical overlays wrapped around the broadcast program. These enabled broadcasters to exploit HbbTV’s interactivity so that users could respond to the ads, but lacked true insertion capability.

Now HbbTV-TA enables full frame-accurate ad insertion, which crucially frees broadcasters from dependence on distributors, mainly pay TV operators, for ad targeting. Irrespective of that broadcast medium, the internet connection allows the broadcaster to interact with the consumer and gather the data needed for targeting directly, subject to the usual restrictions of data privacy.

The greater interest for broadcasters, especially those not to have adopted HbbTV so far, is the convergence towards common standards for addressable advertising that will help achieve scale and critical mass, while attracting brands. HbbTV seems to be increasingly aligned with the DVB in this endeavor.

Indeed, the DVB as we have noted before is in the process of rolling out its own targeted advertising specification complementing HbbTV-TA, with a standard mechanism for signaling the advertisement substitution opportunities in the live TV broadcast. Called DVB-TA, this is similar to HbbTV-TA and converging with it, the basic specification having been published in the DVB BlueBook A178-1 on dynamic substitution of content in linear broadcast, available from the DVB website. Work is ongoing on the signaling part of the specification, which will be published as a separate DVB BlueBook. Both documents will then be forwarded for publication as ETSI standards.

But HbbTV in its current form is still rooted in the broadcast domain and will be following the DVB towards total IP-centricity in its next version. The DVB in 2019 formally ratified the DVB-I standard for broadcast over IP in a spate of announcements bringing together the three key ingredients for IP streaming, that is multicast ABR delivery, low latency and enhanced service discovery. It was the latter that DVB made most of in positioning DVB-I as a long-awaited fix for delivery of linear TV over IP. The key development was technology to bring internet-delivered linear TV up to the standard of traditional broadcast in terms of both video quality and user experience. That is naturally crucial for delivery of addressable TV advertising over the internet via either HbbTV-TA or DVB-TA.

As we observed last month, DVB has recast its technical foundations around new working subgroups all focused on IP video. DVB-I is at the core as the broadcast-broadband hybrid delivery mechanism based on HTTP technology that was approved in November. So, we will not recover that ground, save to reiterate our enthusiasm for DVB’s advocacy of multicast ABR technology with its very own sub-group coined TM-MCAST. It was around July 2019 we first learned of the DVB taking multicast ABR seriously with the unveiling of DVB-I, in tandem with its developments in Low Latency DASH (LL-DASH), an extension of the existing DVB-DASH specification.

DVB-I takes in LL-DASH alongside multicast ABR, both of which were demonstrated at IBC in September 2019. LL-DASH reduces the delay of live OTT channels to that of broadcast channels, with DVB-I claiming ease of use similar to legacy broadcast equipment.

It is through alignment with DVB-I that HbbTV will gradually lose its distinct identity. Already, an HbbTV application can read a DVB-I service list and offer that directly to the user, including both associated broadcast and broadband services. Similarly, DVB-I client applications can run on HbbTV platforms.