Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 February 2020

Dolby, Bitmovin aim to debunk HDR myths – end up making more

US encoding expert Bitmovin and image technology darling Dolby aimed to debunk 5 myths about Dolby Vision and HDR during a webinar this week. In reality, 3 core “myths” were addressed and stretched to look like 5 – pertaining to price, complexity and device availability.

The first concerns the perception of Dolby Vision – the company’s proprietary HDR video format – as a premium feature. Such qualms about price have escalated since the arrival of Samsung’s royalty-free rival HDR10+, as well as competition from InterDigital’s SL-HDR1 and SL-HDR2 (acquired from Technicolor). Panelists tackled this fable by pointing to Dolby Vision’s more than 25 content partners, growing from the handful of premium content partners including Netflix and Hulu when the technology launched back at CES 2016.

Brushing over the issue somewhat, panelists waxed lyrical about Dolby Vision being supported by the 15 top TV brands globally, supported by 10 different SoC partners, various mobile devices, set tops, and PCs from manufacturers the world over. This slide actually killed two birds with one stone, also debunking the fifth and final myth concerning limited device support, so we won’t bother covering that separately.

“Dolby Vision is being adopted globally and at this point it’s almost like table stakes,” commented one panelist, “we’re closing in on 800 movie titles for the home, compared to 260 theatrical features.”

It wasn’t until the Q&A session that the elephant in the room (Samsung) was actually discussed, although Faultline’s more to-the-point questions were not directly answered. “HDR10+ does similar things on Samsung devices but feel free to reach out to Samsung and request support for Dolby Vision on mobiles and TV sets,” jested the panel.

More interestingly on this topic, we learned briefly about the work around HDR being conducted in collaboration with broadcast standards group DVB in Europe. “We have already defined methodology where multiple different HDR systems are placed around the same video signal. Both Dolby Vision, HDR10+ and InterDigital’s technology can all co-exist in the DVB market,” it was explained, painting a vision of cohabitation for the future but not one we see developing without a few blows being dealt.

“Live sports is an area we are actively working with broadcasters, with a large number of trials but still no 24/7 live service on air. We are looking at how to shade HDR cameras and have a single production workflow to generate both SDR and HDR outputs – because you still need a video signal for SDR HD formats. We have put in place tools to enable people to do this but fundamentally this is about learning new techniques,” the panel continued.

Some live events in China have implemented Dolby Vision HDR but the fact of the matter is that most TV ad revenues today still come from SDR services, not HDR, hence why it is prioritized. However, this is changing “almost weekly”, according to the panel.

Second on the myth busters hitlist was “Dolby Vision adds complexity to my workflow” which is where things get interesting.

Panelists made no bones about Dolby Vision adding a little technical complexity in some cases, which is why Dolby came up with the HDR-First workflow to create and analyze HDR images. “This allows for a scene-by-scene explanation of what’s happening (i.e. how bright/dark), then we can map that to SDR. This allows people to optimize workflow in a fraction of the time,” explained the Dolby half of the panel.

The Bitmovin side of the coin weighed in regarding the workflow diagram included here, “When it comes to minimizing complexities, having an encoding platform that accepts one master mezzanine format and then gives all SDR and HDR flavors out is essential to simplifying things on the encoder side.” Basically, this part of the webinar was all about encouraging the industry to deploy an encoder with access to the Dolby Vision SDK.

Next up and in a similar vein to what has already been discussed, was the myth “implementing Dolby Vision is expensive and licensing is complex” which is essentially myths 1 and 2 merged.

“Additional processing is obviously required for Dolby Vision and HDR distribution workflows. And Dolby also works with partners to enable encoding systems, so clients don’t have to worry about licensing – as distribution of Dolby Vision doesn’t require licensing directly from Dolby,” was the short answer on the matter.

The final “myth” to be cracked was about resolution being more important than HDR (which was actually debunked 2 or 3 years ago). Dolby explained that today there is an insufficient understanding of how the human visual system actually works, despite plenty of research being done into the subject. That said, Dolby claimed during the webinar that studies have shown how consumers struggle to see significant differences between 4K and 8K screens from typical viewing distances (averaging 2.7 meters in the home), while HDR benefits viewers irrespective of resolution and distance (unless you have a screen over 85 inches).

Today, it is still required to have separate HDR renditions for all individual content assets. However, the way technology is heading, representatives from both Bitmovin and Dolby spoke excitedly about it being theoretically possible to deliver an HDR stream to an SDR device with some backwards compatibility, to avoid having to encode and deliver two separate renditions.

A Dolby Vision decoder can map everything down to SDR and can even send a Dolby Vision stream to a HDR10 only device and find a way to map content to the capabilities of the display based on the dynamic metadata which these technologies are based on. Clever stuff.

Australian streaming company Stan was selected as the webinar’s exclusive case study to back up the point about Dolby Vision not being as complex as some people think. “For Stan, nothing needed to change. There were no difficulties implementing or scaling. Stan sees value in 4K but saw a need to offer HDR for premium titles. Licensing and pricing is not an issue because our platform offsets CDN and storage costs where the bulk of costs come from,” said Bitmovin.

Stan’s architecture sources content files from an Amazon S3 cloud storage service, then to a Bitmovin encoder which is also hosted on AWS, where Dolby Vision technology is implemented before heading to Akamai’s cloud-based NetStorage before delivery over an Akamai CDN to the end player.

“At the intersection of creation and distribution, Bitmovin’s cloud encoder has enabled us to maintain the highest perceptual quality of our video for internet delivery,” said Stan’s CTO John Hogan.

Meanwhile, the Ultra HD Forum intends to set profiles recommending particular combinations of the different components. It argues that greater resolutions call not just for HDR but also higher frame rates to deliver the full “wow factor”. For example, while say 60 fps might be recommended for 4K, 128 fps would be preferred to accompany 8K.

Still in 2020, the inconsistency of screen brightness ranges associated with HDR has acted as a deterrent for some in the industry and without proper standards has added confusion. Yet Dolby Vision, HDR10+ the HDR Intelligent Tone Management (ITM) technology now owned by InterDigital, have all been gaining momentum.

Indeed, HDR10+ still lags Dolby Vision in TV and movie content, although the gap is narrowing. On the other hand, most dedicated mobile HDR content is in HDR10, the predecessor of HDR10+, although Apple has some Dolby Vision content via iTunes. However, Panasonic, despite being a lead member of the HDR10+ Alliance, now supports Dolby Vision in its flagship GZ2000 OLED TV as well as its 4K Blu-ray players. So, at present, the trend seems to be towards both being supported on the TV and mobile fronts with no immediate sign of either winning out.

That is because the industry is split, and both have their pros and cons. Dolby Vision supports greater color depth at 12 bit rather than 10 bit and higher peak luminance at 10,000 Nits rather than 4,000 for HDR10 and HDR10+.

On the other hand, HDR10+ catches up with Dolby by adding support for dynamic metadata that HDR10 lacks, enabling it to realize its potential by instructing displays to display color as accurately as possible within their luminance and bit depth ranges.

The other advantage HDR10+ has is being open source and royalty free, which Dolby Vision is not. In fact, it was Samsung’s reluctance to pay Dolby royalties that inspired the decision to invest in enhancing HDR10, which otherwise might well have withered on the vine to leave just one HDR standard.

On the smartphone side, Dolby Vision is still quite rare and, so far, has been implemented in software, unlike TVs where it is hardware-based. LG was the first to support Dolby Vision in a number of phones, joined by Apple with the iPhone, but few others do, while leading models from Samsung, Sony, Huawei and Nokia have HDR10+ displays.

For us, the most intriguing takeaway from the joint webinar was not myth debunking but the topic of event-based HDR adoption, particularly for live sports.